My Photo

About theboxtank

Contact Us

theboxtank lab

theboxtank books

« Crisis in American Construction! | Main | Wal-Mart & Atlanta Draw Line in Sand »

August 09, 2004

Comments

Urbanist

Great site!

Your readers may be interested in my new blog, the New (sub)Urbanist which covers suburban sustainability, transportation, land use, and other related information.

http://newurbanist.blogspot.com

Michael Gill

What's URL?
Wow-very impressive you guys! I can't believe I had to "happen" across this, and was not directed.
After further reading...I'll be back with more.
Love
MG

Dalia

All this website is stating is GENTRIFICATION!
The displacement of marginalized and people of color. Do you guys ever think about them?!?

Kpt. Kloss

Your site really nuked me - it's perfect :)))

Urban policymakers in my country should visit your site. Its perfect to show "what_if_scenario" for big box retail and uncontrolled suburbanization.

Mike Peacock

Does anyone know the average or typical size of Walmarts parking lots? I'm writing an article that make reference to this.
Thanks
Mike

Trevor Hull

Wow, I was just told about this website by a co-worker who happened upon Geoff's comments on www.reddomaha.com (great input there, by the way) It's great to see the two (three? with Corey?) of you addressing such a worthy topic... I expected no less. Look forward to reading and exploring more.

from the huge generic city of Lincoln,
trevor

David Hickson

Ok, so Wal-mart has led to some undesirable consequences. but why is it that a super target, or big K, or another major big box retailer seems to skate by their approval processes while wal-mart is chastised for issues that extend well beyond land use? the dilemma that 1st created this issue of weakening the central city retailers has now led to protests against the big giant for other reasons.

keep in mind this is a democratic and free market country we live in. i hear the same about starbucks. just because their global success has led to seeing them all over the place doesn't give us the right to attack them, hiding behind the issues that ARE NOT based in land use.

when you stop buying your toilet paper at costco and actually spend your money in home-grown stores, maybe your arguments aren't hippocritical.

Chris Jaquez

I have to agree with David's comments. It seems most people have no clue about basic economics or how capitalism works. I usually dismiss the rhetoric as that from socialists, professors (who live outside reality), Hollywood Idiots and college kids who will find out in due time how the world works.

It's funny that 'everyone' hates Wal-Mart but Wal-Mart is the 2nd most profitable retailer in the world. Who are these phantom customers? It's also funny that the same fervor and vitriol is not reserved for Target, K-Mart, Costco and other big boxes.

Now, I am not particularly a fan of Wal-Mart or particularly in specific land use environments. However, that is a land use question with Zoning and Design Standards as the operative tool to mitigate the impacts. But that observation is the same for any big box with similar impacts. Wal-Mart should not be treated any different as that would certainly be arbitrary and capricious.

Jim

Perhaps it is because Wal-Mart _is_ the 2nd most profitable retailer that makes it the target. They are in a position to alter the big-box landscape for the better. Home-grown stores are a thing of the past in most areas (even in urban areas) for better or for worse.

However, downtown areas are not a thing of the past and these big-box cooridors need to be fixed. These new communites are merely subdivisions off of a 4 lane road with parking and big boxes. There is only one road, one big area of parking and shopping, this becomes the new downtown, the community is lost. It becomes a 'community' of the line rather than the grid. This is what needs to be fixed as I see absolutely nothing positive about it and Wal-Mart is in a position to start that trend.

Perhaps give back to the community in a physical, inherent way with a better designed package (building and parking) rather than just giving money to the local communites (as they say they do).

Just found this site the other day, I'll be reading from now on. thanks.

Mauricio Contreras

Hi, im write from Chile, South America. You have more information about Wal-Tropolis, its possible to built o is a crazy idea?

Thanks

Maris

Hi friend!
I liked your site!
Good work! ;)

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Search theboxtank


Advertising


Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 04/2004